Spectra vs Medela Breast Pump
Did you know that Spectra and Medela are two of the most popular breast pump brands, accounting for over 60% of the market share in the U.S.? Choosing between them can feel overwhelming, especially with so many models, features, and price points to consider.
As a mom of 5 kids who works full time, I’ve spent literally thousands of hours using breast pumps over the years. But I remember all too clearly how overwhelmed I was with trying to choose the perfect breast pump the first time. And there are even more options available on the market today!
In this article, I will compare Spectra vs Medela breast pumps. Whether you're a working mom, an exclusive pumper, or just looking for a convenient way to manage your milk supply, this comprehensive comparison will help you make an informed choice.
Spectra Vs. Medela Breast Pumps: What are the differences?
I’ve summarized key differences between popular models of Spectra and Medela breast pumps here in this table. Below the table, I will share more details for each feature.
Spectra vs. Medela Breast Pump Comparison
Overview of Spectra and MEdela Breast Pumps
Spectra and Medela are household names in the world of breast pumps, but they cater to slightly different needs.
Spectra, a relatively newer brand, is known for its innovative features like closed systems, quiet operation, and customizable settings.
Medela, on the other hand, has been a trusted name for decades, often recommended by hospitals and lactation consultants for its reliability and user-friendly designs.
Both brands have a loyal following, but their pumps excel in different areas, making your personal preferences and your lifestyle the deciding factors.
I personally have more experience with Spectra pumps (the Spectra S1 has been my main pump for 8 years and counting) but have used Medela as well. Check out my other article on How To Use A Spectra Breast Pump for a full detailed user guide.
Design and Portability
When it comes to design, Spectra pumps stand out for their sleek, modern look and lightweight builds. The Spectra S1 and S2 models, for instance, are designed with convenience in mind. The built-in nightlight and digital display make them perfect for nighttime pumping. However, Spectra pumps are slightly bulkier compared to some of Medela’s compact options.
Medela’s pumps, like the Pump in Style with MaxFlow and Freestyle Flex, are built for moms on the go. These models are compact and come with portable tote bags, making them easy to carry to work or on trips. If portability is a top priority, Medela might have the edge, especially with its lightweight designs and battery-powered options.
You will also want to consider the weight of each pump (scroll back up to the table above). If you will be using your pump in multiple locations, even within your home but certainly if traveling with it or taking it to work, you will want to be aware of its weight. You don’t want to lug around a very heavy pump when there are lighter, more portable options! Both Spectra and Medela have portable options as well as models that are not optimized for that.
Suction Strength and Efficiency
Spectra is known for its natural-feeling suction and adjustable settings. The Spectra S1 and S2 use a closed system that mimics the rhythm of a baby’s nursing, making the pumping experience more comfortable and efficient. These pumps allow you to to adjust both the suction strength and cycle speed based on your individual need.
To learn how to optimize your Spectra pump settings for maximum milk production and comfort, you’ll want to check out this other article I wrote here .
Medela, on the other hand, uses two-phase expression technology, which switches from a faster let-down phase to a slower milk expression phase. This technology is highly effective at extracting milk quickly, which is a big plus for busy moms. However, Medela pumps can sometimes feel stronger and less customizable than Spectra’s options, which might not be ideal for moms with sensitive nipples.
Comfort and Customization
One of the standout features of Spectra pumps is their emphasis on comfort. The ability to fully customize suction levels and speed helps reduce discomfort, especially during extended pumping sessions. Additionally, Spectra’s closed system prevents milk from backflowing into the pump, ensuring good hygiene.
Medela also offers comfort-focused features, such as different breast shield sizes to ensure a proper fit. However, some users report that Medela’s pumps can feel slightly more mechanical compared to Spectra. If comfort is your top priority, Spectra may have the upper hand.
Power Source and Battery Life
Spectra and Medela both offer versatile power options, with each manufacturer having options with built in power and also that require a plug into an outlet.
The Spectra S1 comes with a built-in rechargeable battery, offering up to three hours of cordless pumping. This is perfect for moms who don’t always have access to an outlet (or if, like me, you find yourself pumping in random places like in the car or while making lunch). The Spectra S2, in comparison, must always be plugged in to an outlet in order to function.
Medela pumps, like the Freestyle Flex, also include rechargeable battery options, but some models, such as the Pump in Style, rely on plug-in power or external battery packs.
Regardless of whether you choose Spectra or Medela, is important to check the specifications of the specific pump to understand its power source and battery life. I highly recommend options with an internal rechargable battery like the Spectra S1 or Freestyle Flex.
Accessories and Ease of Cleaning
Spectra includes thoughtful features like a nightlight, timer, and a closed system for easier maintenance. The closed system ensures that milk doesn’t get into the tubing, reducing the need for frequent cleaning.
Click here to learn all about Spectra pump parts.
Medela, while slightly less advanced in terms of built-in features, excels in accessory availability. Medela’s spare parts, including bottles and breast shields, are widely available and easy to replace. However, its open system design can require more cleaning and maintenance than Spectra’s.
Price and Value
Many insurance plans cover both Spectra and Medela pumps, so be sure to check your coverage before making a breast pump purchase. You might be able to get one for no additional charge or highly discounted.
Price is a critical factor when choosing a breast pump. Spectra pumps are generally more affordable than Medela’s hospital-grade models, making them a great choice for moms on a budget. For example, the Spectra S2 is a high-performing pump at a lower price point than comparable Medela options.
Medela pumps, while often pricier, are known for their durability and long-lasting performance.
User Reviews and Experiences
Spectra users rave about the pump’s quiet operation and customizable settings, making it ideal for exclusive pumpers and those who value comfort. I’ve personally loved my Spectra S1 pump for over 8 years and so can personally attest to the durability and effectiveness.
Medela pumps are often praised for their reliability and efficiency, especially in hospital-grade models. Moms who need to pump frequently and want a time-efficient option often choose Medela. However, some users mention that Medela pumps can feel noisier compared to Spectra.
Which Breast Pump Is Right for You?
Ultimately, the choice between Spectra and Medela comes down to your unique needs. If you’re looking for a quiet, customizable pump with comfort-focused features, Spectra might be the perfect fit. On the other hand, if you prioritize portability, efficiency, and a trusted brand name, Medela could be your go-to.
Conclusion
Choosing the right breast pump is a deeply personal decision, but understanding the differences between Spectra and Medela can help you feel confident in your choice. Both brands offer excellent options for different needs, whether you’re an exclusive pumper or juggling a busy lifestyle. Take the time to consider your priorities—comfort, portability, price, or efficiency—and you’re sure to find the perfect pump for your journey. Have questions or personal experiences to share? Drop them in the comments—we’d love to hear from you!
